John Wesley was a man endowed with remarkable abilities. Not least among them was the gift of giving sound and encouraging advice to those who asked his counsel. Though Wesley was a very active man, he encouraged his friends and fellow Methodists to write and share their problems with him. He let them know that he never tired of hearing from them. In this way he was able to fulfill a pastoral role to the entire body of people called Methodists.
For half a century he advised them on such matters as marriage, health, spiritual formation, education, employment, and finances. For half a century his people were instructed, encouraged, and directed by what could be considered timeless wisdom, rooted in God’s Word and good common sense.
It is our desire that through this counsel, given over two centuries ago, you might be thus instructed, encouraged, and directed in the 21st century.
Marriage
John Telford says that during this period of Wesley’s life “he seems to have been consulted on all the love affairs of the Connexion.” 1 Since he had experienced a tragedy in his own marriage, he seemed very anxious that the domestic affairs of his friends and co-laborers would turn out well.
He writes to a George Robinson in 1777 who had apparently lost his first wife, and because he had numerous children, was thinking about hastily remarrying
”Although the number of your children may incite you to it, yet I hope you will not be in haste to make a second choice. Let it be a matter of much prayer and deliberation. Many women will doubtless be offered. But let piety be your first consideration and fortune only the last.” 2
Ann Bolton, a frequent correspondent of Mr. Wesley’s, who he endearingly called Nancy, was engaged to a man who had the appearance of religion but nothing more than that. After breaking off from him she spent a period of time grieving about the incident. The following illustrates Wesley’s direct style of counseling with those who sought his advice.
”You are fretting and grieving yourself because the snare is broken, because your soul is taken out of the net! What deep unthankfulness!…My Nancy, arise and shake yourself from the dust! You have acted wisely and faithfully…He is well pleased with the sacrifice you have made.” 3
Perhaps one of Wesley’s most significant convictions concerning marriage came through in his letter to Elijah Bush in 1781. This local preacher was making plans to marry a woman against the consent of his parents. “I have never in a observation of fifty years known such a marriage attended with a blessing. I know not how it should be since it is flatly contrary to the fifth commandment.” 4 Wesley then preceded to tell Mr. Bush that he (Wesley) did not allow his own mother a positive voice, that is he would not marry a woman because she bid him to; but he would allow her a negative voice, that is he would marry no person if she forbade it.
Health
It would seem that Wesley, if he had not been a preacher, would have made a good doctor, for he was obviously very interested in any health related matters. He was in the habit of collecting homemade remedies for various illnesses and then passing them on to his friends. He frequently discussed helpful ways to prevent illness, and methods to recover health once it was lost. In a letter to Elizabeth Morgan, a friend of Wesley’s who was temporarily retired from her work in order to recover her health, Wesley advocated that she mix reading, meditation, and prayer along with exercise in the open air. He then adds, “And why should you not add that truly Christian diversion, visiting the poor, whether sick or well?” 5
With this last bit of advice, Wesley seems to indicate a belief that therapy often comes to the sick (whether in mind or body) by taking account of those who are worse off. Concerning exercise in the open air, he was a constant advocate. Wesley tells his niece, Sarah Wesley, that she can attain more health in both body and mind by being temperate in sleep. Lying too long in bed would hurt the body by causing nervous diseases, weakness, depression, and headaches. He also maintained that it hurt the mind by weakening the understanding, blunting the imagination, dulling the affections, and infusing a certain kind of softness that is inconsistent with the character of a good soldier of Jesus Christ. 6
On the other hand, the danger of overwork was a concern that Wesley carried for some of his preachers. He cautions John Valton, “Take care you not preach more than your health allows. You must not offer murder for sacrifice.” 7 To Robert Carr Brackenbury he writes, “We are not at liberty to impair our own health in hopes of doing good to others.” 8
Wesley was attuned to the fact that spiritual depression could often be attributed to physical weakness or illness. He endeavors to comfort Ann Bolton with this connection in a letter dated April 24, 1777. Miss Bolton apparently felt like God had deserted or forsaken her. Wesley’s response,
”But this is absolutely impossible.: I deny that such a state ever existed under the sun (that God would desert a Christian). As I observed before, the trouble you feel is in the very root and ground of it, a natural effect of disordered liver, of the corruptible body pressing down the soul.” 9
Worry too was detrimental to good health of body and mind. To a sickly young man not yet 25, Wesley writes,
”With regard to your health, both of body and mind, if you could take one advice it would have a surprising effect. It is this: ‘take not thought for the morrow.’ You know not how much even your body suffers by this.” 10
Employment
A consideration of Christians in every age is the concern of proper employment. How can one be certain that he/she is fulfilling his/her calling? Wesley found much occasion to give advice in this area. For the most part he encouraged, like the Apostle Paul, that his people stay in their present employment.
One traveling preacher, who was laboring under considerable depression of mind because of insinuations from the great adversary, wrote to Wesley requesting that Wesley send a preacher to the circuit in his stead, because he believed he was “out of his place.” Wesley got immediately to the point, “Dear brother, you are indeed ‘out of your place’, for you are reasoning when you ought to be praying.” 11
When Mary Bishop wrote and asked whether he thought she should relinquish her present work for employment in a boarding school, Wesley replied, “You have now a large field of action: you have employment enough, both temporal and spiritual; and you have ease enough. Abide in your calling.” 12
Another preacher wanted to cease being a local minister and become a traveling evangelist. But because of some impediments Wesley discouraged him with the following.
”When a preacher travels without his wife, he is exposed to innumerable temptations. And you cannot travel with your wife till she is so changed as to adorn the gospel. It seems, therefore, all you can do at present is to act as a local preacher.” 13
Sanctification Obtainable by Faith
Wesley seems to have been chosen by God to revive the doctrine of sanctification in a day of corruption and ecclesiastical lethargy. It is obvious that he himself recognized this, for on occasion he stated that God has raised up the Methodists to spread Scriptural holiness across the land.
He was adamant in his belief that holiness was obtainable by faith alone and not by works. He believed that where holiness of heart and life were taught and emphasized, there the whole work of God would prosper in general.
To Hannah Ball he writes, “If the preachers and leaders strongly exhort the believers to go on to perfection, then the entire work of God will prosper among you; otherwise it will languish.” 14
Endeavoring to guide Robert Carr Brackenbury to seek for the blessing of heart purity by faith, Wesley says,
“You must not set the great blessing afar off because you find much war within. Perhaps this will not abate but rather increase till the moment your heart is set at liberty. The war will not cease…but by your attaining the promise. Stand if you look for it by naked faith, why may you not receive it now?” 15
To Lady Maxwell, Wesley writes on May 3, 1777, “There is the prize before you! Look up, believe, and take all you want!” 16
Advice for Preachers and Christian Workers
Wesley spent a great deal of time corresponding with his preachers that he placed in the field of labor. He had a small army of men who were servicing the Methodist fellowships along with the society at large in England, Ireland, and Scotland. Many of these men were untrained, and it fell Wesley’s lot in instruct them in the ways of ministry. His letters reveal a great variety of subjects in which he gave admonition. In regards to preaching, a letter dated February 16, 1977, asserts,
“If any other of the preacher exceed their time (about one hour in the whole service), I hope you will always put them in mind what is the Methodist rule. People imagine the longer the sermon is the more good it will do. This is a grand mistake. The help done on earth God doth it Himself; and He doth not need that we should use many words.” 17
In 1778, Thomas Taylor was stationed at Wednesbury. Upon arrival he found that “Calvinism, Antinomianism, and downright ranterism had so laid waste this country, that there was small hopes of doing much good”. 18 Taylor apparently had fallen into the practice of preaching against these false doctrines incessantly. Wesley’s advice was,
“As to preaching, you ought not to preach against that unscriptural, blasphemous, mischievous doctrine constantly – no, nor very frequently. But you ought now and then to bear a full, strong, express testimony against it; otherwise you are a sinner against God and your people and your own soul.” 19
Wesley advocated that his preachers use as much tact as possible in the presentation of the gospel. However he warned them that at times the plain gospel would give offense and therefore they were not to fear or show fear. He instructed John Mason, “If it be possible, say not one offensive word. But you must declare the plain, genuine gospel, and sooner or later God will give you His blessing.” 20
To another friend,
“Dear Billy, –Never imagine you can be ‘faithful to your trust’ without offending anybody. Regard not that; follow your own conscience without fear or favor. Do the best you can, and you do enough! ‘Angels can do no more.’” 21
One temptation of every Christian worker at some point in their ministry will be the temptation to succumb to discouragement because of a lack of visible results. In a letter to a leader of one of his societies Wesley says, “Sometimes you will be in danger of dejection; when you have labored long in any instance, and see no fruit of your labor. But remember! You will be rewarded according to your labor, nor according to your success.” 22
A Fallen Brother
It can certainly be argued that Wesley was a strict disciplinarian. He lived a disciplined life and he expected his preachers and fellow Christians to live one too. When an erring brother or sister broke the rules of the Society, full discipline was always to be enforced by the leaders. On one occasion Wesley wrote, “I do not admire fair-weather preachers.” 23 And yet beneath this somewhat austere external, Wesley had a great compassion for the fallen, and he clearly counseled others to have it too.
When William Shent, a former Methodist, fell into sin, Wesley wrote the Society at Keighley.
“I have a few questions which I desire may be proposed…
Who was the occasion of the Methodist preachers first setting foot in Leeds? William Shent
Who received John Nelson into his house at his coming thither? William Shent
Who was it that invited me and received me when I came? William Shent
Who was it that stood by me while I preached in the street with stones flying on every side? William Shent
Who was it that bore the storm of persecution for the whole town and stemmed it at the peril of his own life? William Shent
Whose word did God bless for many years in an eminent manner? William Shent’s
By whom were many children now in paradise begotten in the Lord and many now alive? William Shent
Who is he that is ready now to be broken up and turned into the street? William Shent
And does nobody care for this? William Shent fell into sin and was publicly expelled from the Society; but must he be also starved? Must he with his grey hairs and all his children be without a place to lay his head? Can you suffer this? O tell it not in Gath! Where is Gratitude? Where is compassion? Where is Christianity? Where is humanity? Where is concern for the cause of God? Who is a wise man among you? Who is concerned for the gospel? Who has put on bowels of mercy? Let him arise and exert himself in this matter. You here arise as one man and roll away the reproach. Let us set him on his feet once more. It may save both him and his family” 24
Other Religious Affiliations
John Wesley was certainly no religious bigot. Even though the Church of England was at times a “thorn in the flesh” to his work, he never left the Church to the day of his death. He advised the Methodist to follow his example, although he did have second thoughts about this in the last decade of his life.
In two of his sermons, A Caution against Bigotry, and Catholic Spirit, it is plain to see that Wesley had a broad view of the church. However he was not unaware of the difficulty of mixing certain points of theology and ecclesiastical practices in the same organization. Sometimes he called outright for his people to separate themselves from the influences of certain teachings and yet to maintain a loving spirit. This is demonstrated in the following letter to Mrs. Crosby. “Fire and water cannot well dwell together, nor warm Calvinists and Arminians. Let us love them and help them all we can. But the less intercourse our people have with them the better.” 25
At other times and under other circumstances Wesley’s advice seemed to indicate that he felt like the Methodists should associate with “other” Christians if they could do it without harming their own faith. In 1781, Wesley received a letter from a group of men who were members of one of his societies. These men were to be noted for a loving spirit and unblamable conversation. They reminded Wesley that for years he and his preachers had told them that they should attend the Church of England services. And yet at these very services they were constantly hearing Calvinism lauded and Christian Perfection exploded.
They asked Wesley if he thought they could profit from such sermons, and if they were not providing themselves with a means of filling their hearts with prejudice against his preachers and the truth. Furthermore they were asked after the sermon if they liked it. Here they either had to dissemble or offend the ones who asked.
This letter caused Wesley to do some soul-searching. After careful deliberation he returned the following answer.
“It is a delicate as well as important point, on which I hardly know how to answer. I cannot lay down any general rule. All I can say at present is, If it does not hurt you, hear them; if it does, refrain. Be determined by your own conscience. Let every man in particular act as he is fully persuaded in his own mind.” 26
Wealth and Finances
“Make all you can…save all you can…and give all you can” is the well-known admonition of Wesley concerning money”. 27 By the records left us it seems clear that Wesley followed his own advice. He took seriously the claims of Jesus that money could prove to be a hindrance in entering the kingdom of God. He also knew that Christianity by its very nature teaches a man to be industrious and wise. This tends to produce wealth which will in turn eventually produce self-indulgence rather than self-denial that is so necessary for one to follow Christ.
To avoid this vicious cycle, Wesley deeply believed that the Christian should give away his excess money to Christian causes and the poor. In this way he would meet the real needs of others and at the same time he would remove a snare from his own life. Several letters during this period of his life underscore this conviction.
To Miss March he wrote,
“I do not remember the making mention of covetousness: but it is likely I might; for I am exceedingly afraid of it, lest it should steal unawares (as it always comes in disguise) either upon myself or my friends. I know no way to escape it but (having saved all we can) to give all we can. I think this is at present your rule as well as mine; and I trust it always will be.” 28
To Mary March he wrote,
“Two-thirds of those who are grown rich are greatly degenerated. They do not, will not save all they can in order to give all they can. And without doing this they cannot grow in grace; nay, they continually grieve the Holy Spirit of God.” 29
”Oh who can bear riches! Who can gain money without in some measure losing grace!” 30
Wesley reminded Mrs. Woodhouse that in the face of death, “What do riches avail?” He proceeds, “In such circumstances you are richer than them all. You know in whom you have believed…you have in heaven a better and more enduring substance.” 31
While excess wealth should be avoided, so should debt, especially in the ministry. To Samuel Bradburn he gave the following instruction, “You must stop local preachers who are loaded with debt.” 32
Education
Any serious student of John Wesley will soon discover that Wesley had a great love for learning. Study was with Wesley a way of life. His formal schooling included a Master’s degree from Oxford, but his constant reading and wide experience gave him a grasp of things far beyond his years at Oxford. He once declared that his goal was to be holy and scholarly.
However, Wesley knew that education could be a stumbling block for some. He taught that it was unquestionably the Christian’s duty to cultivate his understanding, but that he should beware of pride and the thinking of himself more highly than he ought to think. Also there would be the danger that knowledge would be stressed more than love. “We allow it is of great value in its place,” wrote Wesley, “that is, in subordination to holiness as the handmaid of love.” 33
After Mary Bishop started a Christian school for children in Publow, she received a letter from Mr. Wesley detailing some of the concerns he had for the school. He felt that her students lacked simplicity. That they had good breeding and culture was clear, but they seemed to be without spirituality and the mind that was in Christ. He insists that her first goal should be to make her students Christian, and only then genteel. 34
Wesley often prescribed a course of study for those who didn’t have the opportunity to take higher education. He counseled his niece, Sarah Wesley, to read the Bible for an hour every day because “all you learn is to be referred to this, either directly or remotely.” 35
In addition, she should study English grammar; arithmetic; geography; logic; philosophy; history of the ancient world, of the church, of the Reformation, of England, of the Puritans, of America. She was also to study poetry and theology. 36 Wesley not only told her what subjects to study, he also gave her a list of textbooks.
Spiritual Encouragement
Wesley had a tremendous gift of encouragement. This undoubtedly was the reason he was so loved by the people. He always seemed to have a “word in season” that ministered grace to the hearer. The following is illustrative.
To Ann Bolton,
”It is a great step toward Christian resignation to be thoroughly convinced of that great truth that there is no such thing as chance in the world; that fortune is only another name for providence. An event the cause of which does not appear we commonly say ‘comes by chance.’ Oh no: it is guided by an unerring hand; it is the result of infinite wisdom and goodness. Such are all the afflictive circumstances that have followed you in constant succession almost from your childhood.” 37
To Hester Ann Roe,
“We know, indeed, that these (as well as all things) are ordered by unerring Wisdom, and are given us exactly at the right time and in due number, weight, and measure. And they continue no longer than is best; for chance has no share in government of the world.” 38
To Ann Bolton,
“And you cannot insist too much on that point – that, whatever our past experience has been, we are now more or less acceptable to God as we more or less improve the present moment.” 39
To Mrs. Johnston,
“I make no doubt but He will hear the prayers on behalf of your whole family; but the time and manner of answering our prayers He reserves in His own power. And He has given you a token for good, already you have one, if not more, children that love and fear Him; and the rest are not such enemies of the gospel as persons of their rank usually are. You have reason to thank God for what He has done, and to expect all that He has promised.” 40
Finally, no discussion of Wesley’s pastoral letters would be complete without some reference to the letters he wrote to a man named Alexander Knox. Knox, it seems, was a young man is his early twenties who suffered exceedingly from spiritual depression as a result of a physical ailment and a constitution plagued with an inclination to worry, fear, and melancholy.
Letter after letter flows from Wesley’s pen to Knox during this time. They are filled with an abundance of love and compassion. It is evident that Wesley has taken this struggling young person to his heart (as a son in the gospel) and is determined to nurture him back to spiritual and physical wholeness.
Because of Knox’s incessant self-condemnation Wesley writes,
”Some time since, I was reading an account of a person in France, whom his confessor absolutely forbade (for such a time) to think of his sins and ordered him ‘to think only of the mercies of God in Christ.’ It had an admirable effect on that desponding man. I know not but it might have the same upon you. Do not look down, but look up. Let not the corruptible body press down the soul, and give no place to the evil one, who would keep you continually poring on the dark side of the prospect. There is good determined concerning you, and not evil. God has not forsaken you.” 41
In another letter, Wesley advises Knox that it is good to know one’s self, but that one should not stop there, as he (Knox) is so apt to do. This knowledge on oneself should lead us to know Christ who loves and saves sinners. 42 He encourages Knox to “break through the fear, which is a snare of the devil.” 43And to “trust in God.” Resist every distrustful thought the moment it is injected. God is on your side. Believe not the old murderer who tells you the contrary.” 44
__________
1 John Telford, The Letters of the Rev. John Wesley, vol 6 (London: Epworth Press), 248.
2 Ibid., 270-271.
3 Ibid., 279-280.
4 John Telford, The Letters of the Rev. John Wesley, vol 7 (London: Epworth Press), 83-84.
5 Ibid., 51.
6 Ibid., 75.
7 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 380.
8 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 90.
9 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 261, 262.
10 Ibid., 308.
11 Ibid., 369.
12 Ibid., 158.
13 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 32.
14 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 360.
15 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 33.
16 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 264.
17 Ibid., 255.
18 Ibid., 294.
19 Ibid., 295.
20 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 37-38.
21 Ibid., 38.
22 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 353.
23 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 68.
24 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 334.
25 Ibid., 331.
26 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 92-93.
27 The Work of John Wesley, vol 6 (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House), 124-136.
28 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 263.
29 Ibid., 288.
30 Ibid., 255.
31 Ibid., 251-252.
32 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 68.
33 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 335.
34 Telford, Letters, vol 7, 62-63.
35 Ibid., 82.
36 Ibid., 83.
37 Ibid., 45-46.
38 Telford, Letters, vol 6, 339.
39 Ibid., 297.
40 Ibid., 310-311.
41 Ibid., 320.
42 Ibid., 309.
43 Ibid., 377.
44 Ibid., 314.